Welcome to Arni’s Lafayette Pay-Less
Arni’s Lafayette Pay-Less, located at 2513 Maple Point Dr, is a beloved culinary destination in Lafayette, IN. Renowned for its crispy thin-crust pizza and fresh toppings, this eatery has been a favorite among locals for years. Signature offerings like the Original BBQ pizza, Texas BBQ sandwich, and the popular Arni's Junior salad, complemented by their homemade blue cheese dressing, keep cravings satisfied. The welcoming and consistent service creates a comforting atmosphere, making every visit feel like a nostalgic trip down memory lane. While the decor may be dated, the food remains simply unforgettable, drawing loyal patrons time and time again.
Arni’s Lafayette Pay-Less: Reviews & Ratings
I love Arni's, so it's great that there is one on the south side here. Now I'm craving an Arni's Junior salad with their awesome homemade blue cheese dressing. It's one of my favorite nostalgic comfort foods! :)
Always good food! Think crust, crispy pizza. Fresh toppings. Original BBQ pizza is my favorite. Texas BBQ sandwich and Hot Ham & Cheese sandwich are delicious. Arni's Jr Salad is the best! Their garlic bread is awesome. Always have great service.
I only get to stop here every few years when I'm visiting family. Best pizza anywhere. I've never had pizza from an other restaurant that even comes close to being my #1
Been going there since i was 4 years old and iam in my 60's. Awesome pizza and service. When eating in i dont care for the surroundings and the carpet looks really nasty. Over all tho its the only place i get my pizza at least 3 or 4 times a month.
To us they have the best and we tried all pizza kings in Lafayette, not greasy at all if you been to any other you know what I mean. The ladies behind the counter preparing said must be there oven cause that is the only thing deference from the other stores, according to the lady I talked to but for us the best.
Best known for their delicious pizza and salads, but with an excellent variety of great food at reasonable prices. Arni's is a local icon with the appropriate slogan: "Meet you at Arni's!" Popular for meetings, celebrations, and family get-togethers. One of those places former residents must visit when they're in town.
This place is a dinning must for my family. Food and service are great, portion sizes are big and the menu has something for Everyone! Been a customer since the 80's lol
Always a treat to eat here with so many delicious items on the menu. I almost got a stromboli, one of my fave sandwiches of theirs, until I spotted the Windsor (ham & turkey on Texas toast topped with cheddar cheese sauce and chopped green onions) so I got that instead and wasn't disappointed at all. It had been years since I had one and forgot how good it is. A cup of chicken dumplings soup and an Arni's Jr rounded out the meal. Staff is always friendly and the kid friendly seating area has a lot to look at with old and current pics of Lafayette and West Lafayette on the walls. Very accommodating to large groups as well! Medium pricing, but you also get your money's worth.
Location
-
2513 Maple Point Dr, Lafayette, IN 47905, United States Hotline: +1 765-446-2200
Welcome to Arni’s Lafayette Pay-Less, a cherished gem located at 2513 Maple Point Dr, Lafayette, IN. With a strong reputation amongst locals, Arni's is not just a pizza destination; it’s a nostalgic experience that has brought families together for decades. Whether you're craving their fan-favorite thin crust pizza or a comforting Arni's Junior salad, each dish is crafted with quality ingredients that keep customers coming back for more.
As highlighted by loyal patrons, the think crust pizza here speaks volumes. Customers rave about the crispy texture and the abundance of fresh toppings. One regular mentions the original BBQ pizza as their favorite, while others can’t resist the allure of the Texas BBQ sandwich or the Hot Ham & Cheese sandwich, testifying to the diverse menu offerings that cater to every palate.
The experience at Arni’s is about more than just the food; it's about the memories created over shared meals. For many, like customer Marilyn Michelle Strong-Koontz, the Arni’s Junior salad with their famous homemade blue cheese dressing evokes a sense of nostalgia, making it a beloved comfort food. Another customer, Carrie Hartman, notes consistent quality and great service, reinforcing the welcoming atmosphere that defines this establishment.
Despite some critiques regarding the ambiance, including mentions of the carpet, it’s the pizza that keeps patrons loyal. As Derek Hensley points out, Arni’s pizza is simply unmatched, standing above the rest in a city filled with options. Many have tried various pizza spots in Lafayette, yet Arni’s continues to claim its title as the best.
If you're seeking a place that serves delicious, ungreasy pizza paired with exceptional service, look no further than Arni’s Lafayette Pay-Less. Stop by for a meal that you won't soon forget, and see for yourself why this local favorite holds a special place in the hearts of its community.